The $5 Million Sunburn: Is Your Cruise Ship Pool Deck a Hidden Hazard?

Imagine this: You’re lounging on the Lido Deck of the Carnival Magic, the Caribbean sun is shining, and the pool is calling your name. You stand up from your lounge chair, take a few steps toward the water, and suddenly, it feels like you’ve stepped onto a stovetop.

For most of us, this is just a quick "oops" moment followed by a frantic hop back to our flip-flops. But for one Florida man, those twenty steps allegedly turned a dream vacation into a medical nightmare and a $5 million maritime lawsuit.

At MyCruiseCabin.com, we’re all about helping you see exactly what your cabin and ship look like before you sail. But sometimes, the most important thing to "see" is the potential hazard hiding right under your feet. Let’s break down the scorching details of the Jorge Luis Alverio Núñez case and why the material on that pool deck is now under a legal microscope.

The 20 Steps That Cost Millions

Snap! That’s the sound of a vacation hitting a brick wall. In May 2025, Jorge Luis Alverio Núñez was enjoying a sailing on the Carnival Magic. According to the legal complaint filed in the Southern District of Florida, Núñez was on the Lido Deck (Deck 10) during a typical sunny afternoon. He walked approximately 20 steps barefoot from the pool area to his lounge chair.

By the time he reached his chair, the damage was done. Núñez allegedly suffered severe second-degree burns on the soles of both feet. We’re not talking about a mild "sunburn" here; we’re talking about deep tissue damage that required hospitalization, significant medical treatment, and, according to the lawsuit, has left him with permanent disfigurement and mental anguish.

The Culprit: What is API Syntheteak?

Share! Did you know that the "wood" you see around most cruise ship pools isn't actually wood? Most modern ships, including those in the Carnival Cruise Line fleet, use a synthetic material designed to look like teak.

The material specifically named in the lawsuit is API Syntheteak. On paper, it’s a brilliant invention. It’s durable, resistant to saltwater, and provides that classic maritime aesthetic without the high maintenance of real wood. However, the lawsuit alleges a major flaw: the manufacturer supposedly provided data to Carnival as far back as 2014 showing that this material can absorb solar radiation at an alarming rate.

In the heat of a Caribbean afternoon, these synthetic surfaces can reach temperatures high enough to cause instant skin burns. The lawsuit claims that the deck was "unreasonably and dangerously hot" and that Carnival failed to provide any warning signs or cooling measures to protect passengers who might naturally walk barefoot in a pool area.

A Pattern of "Hot" Incidents

Discover! This wasn't an isolated "freak accident," according to the legal filing. Núñez’s attorneys have been doing their homework, and the numbers they’ve uncovered are staggering. The lawsuit cites at least 25 prior burn incidents and 42 passenger complaints related to overheated deck materials on Carnival ships between 2019 and 2025.

Perhaps most shocking are the claims of extreme injuries. The complaint alleges that Carnival was aware of at least two prior passengers whose burns from these decks were so severe that they eventually required the amputation of a foot or leg below the knee. If these allegations are proven true, it suggests that the cruise line had "constructive notice", legal speak for "they definitely knew this was a problem", and yet continued to use the material without adequate warnings or modifications.

Why Didn't Anyone Say Anything?

One of the central arguments in the case is whether the danger was "open and obvious." Usually, if you see a fire, you know not to touch it. But a cruise ship deck looks like a safe place to walk. When you're at the pool, you expect the floor to be, well, floor-like.

Núñez argues that there were no signs, no "Caution: Hot Surface" placards, and no shade structures or water misters in the area to indicate that the deck had reached a dangerous temperature. For a first-time cruiser or even a seasoned veteran, the idea that 20 steps on a pool deck could lead to a $5 million injury is something few would anticipate.

Protect Your Paws: Practical Tips for the Lido Deck

Don't let a "hot foot" ruin your trip! While we wait to see how the courts handle the Carnival Magic lawsuit, there are smart steps you can take to keep your feet safe.

• Never assume a surface is cool: Even if other people are walking around, their skin might be tougher or they might just be moving fast. Always do a quick "tap test" with your toe before committing to a barefoot walk.

• Invest in high-quality water shoes: Flip-flops are great for the beach, but for walking around the Ports or the Lido deck, water shoes provide better grip and heat protection.

• Stick to the blue (or light) areas: Many ships use different colors of decking. Darker colors absorb more heat. If you must go barefoot, try to stay on the lighter-colored sections of the deck.

• The "Shadow Rule": If there's no shade, there's no safety. Surfaces in direct sunlight during the peak hours of 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM are at their most dangerous.

To stay safe and comfortable, we highly recommend packing a pair of dedicated cruise shoes.

Amazon link to VIFUUR Quick-Dry Water Shoes
As an Amazon Associate, MyCruiseCabin.com earns from qualifying purchases.

Amazon link to Crocs Unisex-Adult Classic Clogs
As an Amazon Associate, MyCruiseCabin.com earns from qualifying purchases.

Smarter Booking Starts with Research

The $5 million lawsuit is a sobering reminder that cruise ships are massive, complex environments where safety isn't always a given. That’s why we built the Cabin Photo Database. When you can see authentic, user-generated photos of every corner of a ship: from the balcony of your specific cabin to the layout of the pool deck: you can make smarter booking decisions.

If you’re planning a trip on the Carnival Magic or any other ship, take a look at our Ships gallery to see exactly what the decking looks like. You can also join the conversation in our cruise line discussion forums to see if other passengers have reported "hot deck" issues on specific vessels.

The Bottom Line

Whether this lawsuit results in a massive payout or a quiet settlement, it has already served as a major "cautionary tale" for the industry. Cruise lines are likely to face increasing pressure to either swap out these synthetic materials or install much more aggressive cooling systems.

Until then, keep your flip-flops close and your eyes on the ground. Your feet (and your bank account) will thank you.

What do you think? Is a $5 million lawsuit a fair response to a hot deck, or should passengers take more responsibility for their own safety? Have you ever felt the burn on a Lido deck? Leave a comment below and share your "scorching" stories with the community!